I struggled for 17 years with the decision by this house’s prior owner to use tongue-and-groove pine boards as decking material. I don’t care how much wood preservative or paint you dump onto pine boards, they’re going to rot, especially when they make up the surface of a flat porch or deck.
One of our friendly relatives gave us a big squeegee to wipe off water from the deck. I confess: I rarely used it. I’m not sure how much good it would have done because, even though those tongues fit tightly into those grooves, plenty of water worked its way into the joints and stayed there squeegee or not.
So, for most of those 17 years, at least one summer day was spent replacing the worst of the decayed boards. I rarely replaced entire boards, choosing instead to cut away the bad sections. It was hokey, but I had other priorities and nobody (that I’m aware of anyway) crashed through and fell to their death on the brick patio below.
When the columns supporting the deck showed signs of rot in 2007, I knew the bullet needed to be bitten. All new columns were purchased and the pine got cut up for kindling. The new deck is pressure-treated. It’s sturdy and will last forever but it leaves something to be desired. The tongue-and-groove pine, when freshly painted, was more aesthetically pleasing than the run-of-the-mill pressure-treated planks that replaced them.
To an extent, I felt giving up on the high-maintenance pine was capitulation. Was I on a slippery slope that would lead to, God forbid, vinyl siding or replacement of the roof slate with asphalt shingles?
Vinyl siding. Pressure-treated decking. Asphalt roofing material. None of it was available when this house was built and I do my best to avoid modern stuff. However, the deck tonight is covered with snow. In the past, when the structure was still pine, every snowstorm got me to thinking about how all that white stuff was just water waiting to soak into those vulnerable cracks. I guess I can live with one less thing to worry about.












